Turkey’s Counter-terrorism campaign discredited

FIERY PROTEST: Protesters burn an effigy of Turkish Muslim cleric Fethullah Gulen, founder of the Gulen movement, during a demonstration at Taksim Square, in Istanbul. Gulen has been accused by President Recep Tayyip Erdogan of allegedly orchestrating the July 15, 2016 failed coup. Picture: Sedat Suna/EPA/African News Agency (ANA)

Turkey’s propaganda justifying its mass detentions and torture of followers of the Gulen movement as part of a counter-terrorism effort is being thoroughly discredited on multiple fronts. Yesterday Human Rights Watch launched its 2018 World Report, documenting the rise in Turkey of allegations of torture in police custody, and the country’s widespread misuse of counter-terrorism laws. Accounts from victims are of beatings, stress positions and rape. The report emphasizes the enormous pressure exerted by the government on the courts and prosecutors, and the increased restrictions on the media after hundreds of media outlets have been closed down. Turkey is the world leader in jailing journalists.

Much of the repression is with a view to decimating the Gulen movement, which used to be President’s Recep Tayyip Erdogan’s greatest ally, and helped bring him to power in 2003. Fethullah Gulen, who the government now brands as a terrorist, is the movement’s spiritual leader – a moderate Muslim cleric and Turkish intellectual in self-imposed exile in the US. He has long preached an inclusive brand of Sunni Islam, and a message of cooperation and tolerance, and his movement has run a network of Hizmet schools in 170 countries.

Gauteng Premier David Makhura recently lauded the contribution of the Star Colleges (Hizmet schools) to education in South Africa as being phenomenal. The StarCollege in KZN came 4th in the country in terms of the recent matric results, and the Star College in the Western Cape came 6th. Last month Makhura told Hizmet teachers, “I am not very happy with the way the Turkish government is treating a lot of you who have been declared terrorists. If terrorists are what you are, then I think I would love to be a terrorist.”

The Hizmet schools have been highly successful in delivering education in developing countries, but the Turkish government has been on a campaign to get them closed down. In many cases teachers and principals of the Hizmet schools have been abducted and taken back to Turkey.

Human Rights Watch deputy Asia director Phil Robertson has publicly expressed concern about the fact that “many of the Turkish nationals being snatched from other countries face mistreatment and torture, long periods in pre-trial detention, and at the end, a trial on trumped up charges before a court that fails to follow fair trial standards.”

News reports have so far documented abductions of Hizmet teachers having taken place in Myanmar and Malaysia last May, Pakistan in October, and Afghanistan in December. The detainees are allegedly subjected to severe human rights abuses, but Erdogan makes no apologies – in a public rally in December he called on Turks to show no mercy to the Gulen movement.

According to news reports, pro-government columnist Cem Kucuk recently called for Turkish intelligence to kill family members of  FETO (the Gulen movement), and columnist Hüseyin Adalan advocated killing the members and babies of FETO, calling it a religious obligation. “Those who show compassion [for them] must also be killed accordingly,” he said.

This is the type of hysteria being stirred up by the government’s propaganda machine, far in excess of anything seen in the McCarthy era in the US in the 1950s. Consider the fact that to date 151,967 Gulen members have been dismissed from their jobs on the government’s instructions, and131,995 detained. On Monday this week, detention warrants were issued for a further 81 people who work for the High Education Foundation, due to their alleged links to the Gulen movement. In just the first two weeks of this year, the government detained 1,188 alleged Gulenists.

The reason the government gives for the ongoing witchhunt is the allegation that followers of the Gulen movement within the military had staged the attempted coup in July 2015, and that Gulen himself had been the mastermind. But Gulen has categorically denied that and denounced the coup itself. International authorities have found no evidence for Turkey’s claims or its designation of the Gulen movement as a terrorist organisation, which is why the US has refused to extradite Gulen to Turkey.

But the agenda of the Turkish authorities goes far beyond the attempted coup, but is about the need to neutralise a movement that became a political threat when its followers within the judiciary and police started exposing corruption within the government’s ruling inner circle in December 2013. A prime suspect in the major corruption investigation at the time was Reza Zarrab, a Turkish Iranian gold trader. But the Turkish government moved swiftly to shut down the corruption investigations by removing prosecutors and reassigning police. Zarrab was criminally charged in the US and spent a year in a US prison, but last November turned star witness in his own trial testifying against Turkey’s then-Economy Minister about how bribes were paid to him and other senior officials worth tens of millions of dollars.

Turkish efforts to destroy the reputation of Fethullah Gulen in the US have also been exposed. In March last year, former US National Security Adviser Michael Flynn formally registered with the Justice Department as a “foreign agent” and admitted that he had lobbied on behalf of the Turkish government while he was Donald Trump’s campaign adviser. According to paperwork filed with the Justice Department by Flynn’s lawyer, his company was paid at least US$530,000 between August and November 2016 for the lobbying work. Flynn had criticised the Obama administration for “harboring” Fethullah Gulen, and not being supportive enough of Erdogan. 

From the widespread reports of torture and detention without trial of Gulenists, to the near total control of the executive over the judiciary and media, to the government’s attempts to cover up the corruption of senior officials, and its underhanded efforts to get Gulen extradited, its “counter-terrorism” campaign has been exposed as a farce, and the abandonment of the rule of law.


Shannon Ebrahim is the Group Foreign Editor at Independent Media